When it comes to trading, few topics stir up more debate than Forex signal services. Are they legit? Are they a scam? Do they really help traders succeed? In this article, we’ll explore these questions with Edge-Forex as a prime example—because let’s be real, we’re about as close to a reliable signal provider as it gets.

There’s a lot of noise out there—conflicting opinions, exaggerated claims, and a ton of skepticism. Babypips, for instance, has made several bold statements about signal services that deserve a closer look. So, let’s break things down, clarify some myths, and have a real conversation about what Forex signal services actually offer.

What Do Forex Signal Services Really Do?

According to Babypips, Forex signal services are basically like trading robots—just without the trade execution. But that’s a pretty one-dimensional take.

Forex signal services offer trade suggestions based on technical and/or fundamental analysis. These signals help traders—especially beginners—identify opportunities in the market without having to spend hours analyzing charts or news feeds.

There are two main types of signals:

• Manual Signals: Created by human analysts who study market conditions.
• Automated Signals: Generated by algorithms or bots using predefined rules.

Delivery methods include:

• SMS alerts
• Email notifications
• App integrations
• Direct-to-platform notifications

And they’re based on two primary analysis types:

• Technical Analysis: Relies on price patterns, indicators, and chart history.
• Fundamental Analysis: Focuses on economic news, indicators, and sentiment.

Signal providers often offer both free and paid versions, with free options being limited in scope and paid subscriptions offering more detailed and frequent alerts.

Want a quick breakdown? Check out our video here:
Watch Now

The Rationale Behind Trade Signals Isn’t a Mystery

Babypips argues that traders don’t know how a signal is generated. They claim that users blindly follow signals without understanding the “why.” Let’s address that.

While not all providers break down their entire methodology, it’s definitely possible to understand the reasoning behind a signal. A trader simply needs to analyze:

• Recent economic indicators
• Key chart patterns
• Major news events

That’s the basis for sound trading decisions—and the very same foundation used by serious signal providers. If you want to know why a signal suggests buying EUR/USD, all you have to do is examine the market’s technical and fundamental context.

Good traders—and good signal providers—also focus on:

• Risk management
• Risk-reward ratios
• Protective stop losses

So no, signals aren’t “random.” They’re backed by analysis. It’s just not always spoon-fed in the way critics expect.

Speed Matters: Real-Time Signals in a Fast-Moving Market

Timing is everything in Forex.

The best signal providers don’t just analyze well—they deliver quickly. At Edge-Forex, for example, we use real-time data feeds and cutting-edge delivery tools to ensure our signals reach traders fast.

A few seconds can make the difference between profit and loss. That’s why immediacy and reliability are key. And yes, those things cost money to build and maintain—hence the business model.

“If They’re So Good, Why Share the Signals?”

Babypips poses this question as if it’s a mic-drop moment.

Let’s flip it: If knowledge is so valuable, why do schools exist?

Signal providers, like any other business, exist to make money by helping others make money. Just because a signal provider shares trades doesn’t mean they aren’t trading them themselves. In fact, we at Edge-Forex do exactly that—we trade the very signals we share.

It’s not about giving away money—it’s about creating value that keeps traders coming back.

Why Share Signals?

• It’s a scalable business model.
• It builds brand trust in a volatile industry.
• It helps newer traders gain insight and direction.
• It allows professionals to leverage expertise into income.

So no, sharing signals isn’t shady—it’s smart business.

Are There Scammers Out There? Absolutely.

Let’s be clear: Some people do sell garbage signals with wild claims. Anyone promising you’ll make “a bajillion dollars overnight” is lying.

We agree with Babypips here—due diligence is non-negotiable.

But here’s where things go sideways. Babypips tends to paint all signal services with the same brush. They sow distrust while conveniently leaving out the fact that they themselves offer:

• Newsletters
• Blogs
• Calendars
• “Premium” content
• Memberships

Which, ironically, are also based on third-party analysis. Isn’t that the very thing they warn you against?

What Makes Edge-Forex Different?

We don’t just talk the talk—we trade our own signals. Our results are public. Our strategy is open-source. You can view everything:

View Our Trading Results:
Edge-Forex FXBlue Account

We also offer:

• Weekly live sessions
• Telegram Q&A with traders
• Daily blogs and analysis
• No paywalls, no upsells

Here’s what you’ll find on our site:

• Real-time technical and fundamental analysis
• Insights on market-moving news and world events
• Tutorials on trading concepts
• A transparent record of our trades and strategy
• An open door to talk to us—anytime

And yes, we trade with our own capital.

Final Thoughts: Do Your Own Research (Seriously)

If there’s one takeaway from this article, it’s this: Don’t trust anything blindly.

Do your research.

• Check track records
• Ask questions
• Read reviews
• Join free groups
• Watch how they trade

Transparency, integrity, and consistency are what matter in Forex—not loud opinions.

Check Out Our Latest Blog:
The Inflation Fight Continues – How Markets Are Reacting