Brokerage account sales are a crucial aspect of managing investments, but they can be unsettling if they occur without your consent or awareness. When you discover that stocks in your brokerage account have been sold, it’s natural to feel concerned. However, these sales often happen for legitimate reasons. Whether through a discretionary account or due to a margin call, brokerage firms have specific rules to guide such actions.

Understanding these processes will help you protect your investments and avoid surprises in the future. In this article, we will dive deep into the reasons behind brokerage account sales and how you can safeguard your financial interests.

What Are Brokerage Account Sales?

A brokerage account is where you store and manage your investments, such as stocks, bonds, and mutual funds. Brokerage account sales refer to the selling of securities (stocks or other assets) within your account, either by your broker or by automatic mechanisms triggered by specific conditions.

These sales can occur in two major scenarios:

• Discretionary account sales: Here, the broker has the authority to make decisions and execute trades without needing your approval for each action.
• Margin call sales: If you have a margin account, the broker may sell securities to fulfill a margin call if your equity falls below the required maintenance level.

Both scenarios can result in unexpected brokerage account sales, but they are governed by specific rules designed to protect both you and the brokerage firm.

Understanding Discretionary Account Sales

A discretionary account, also called a managed account, allows your broker or financial advisor to make trading decisions on your behalf. When you open such an account, you sign an agreement giving the broker permission to buy and sell securities based on your agreed-upon investment policy statement (IPS). Your IPS outlines your investment goals, risk tolerance, and specific restrictions that guide the broker’s decision-making process.

How Discretionary Accounts Work

In a discretionary account, your broker has the autonomy to act without needing your explicit approval for each trade. However, this power isn’t absolute. The broker’s actions must align with the guidelines set forth in the IPS, and they must always act in your best interest. The broker will select stocks, bonds, and other securities that match your investment objectives. For instance, if your IPS states that you prefer conservative investments, the broker will avoid high-risk stocks.

The benefit of having a discretionary account is convenience. If you trust your broker’s expertise, they can manage your portfolio actively without waiting for your permission on every decision. The drawback is that you may not always be aware of every trade made on your behalf.

Potential Concerns with Discretionary Account Sales

If a broker sells stocks from your discretionary account, you might feel concerned if you disagree with their decisions. For example, if the broker sells securities you weren’t comfortable with or fails to follow your IPS, you could have grounds for a complaint.

If you find yourself in this situation, you should immediately reach out to the brokerage firm. Explain your concerns in writing and request an investigation into whether the broker acted outside the guidelines of your IPS. The firm will usually address such issues promptly. If you feel unsatisfied with the firm’s response, you can also contact regulatory bodies like the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to file a formal complaint.

Margin Calls and Forced Liquidation

Another reason for brokerage account sales is a margin call. This occurs if you have a margin account and the value of your investments declines. A margin account allows you to borrow money from the broker to purchase more securities than you could with just your own funds. This borrowing is secured by the assets in your account. If the value of those assets drops significantly, the broker may issue a margin call to protect their loan.

What Is a Margin Call?

A margin call occurs when the equity in your margin account falls below the minimum level required by the broker. The broker will require you to deposit additional funds or sell some of your securities to bring the account back into compliance. If you fail to meet the margin call, the broker has the authority to sell some of your holdings to cover the debt. This is done automatically, and the broker may sell whatever securities are necessary, regardless of your preferences.

How Forced Liquidation Works

If you do not meet the margin call within the specified time frame, the broker can initiate forced liquidation. This means that the broker will sell enough of your assets to restore the account to the required equity level. It’s crucial to understand that the broker does not need your approval to do this. The goal is to protect the broker’s interests and ensure that the loan is repaid.

In some cases, the broker may sell your most volatile or least liquid assets to cover the margin call. For example, if you hold stocks in both large-cap companies and smaller, riskier companies, the broker may prioritize selling the riskier stocks first.

Avoiding Margin Calls and Forced Liquidation

To avoid the stress of margin calls and forced liquidation, it’s important to carefully monitor your margin account. Here are some tips to help prevent margin-related issues:

• Maintain a buffer: Always keep a margin cushion in your account. Having extra funds can help you avoid dipping below the required maintenance level.
• Regularly monitor account performance: Stay on top of your investments, especially if they are highly volatile.
• Deposit additional funds proactively: If your account value starts to dip close to the margin requirement, deposit more funds to avoid a margin call.

Example of Forced Liquidation in Action

Let’s say you have a margin account with $10,000 worth of securities and a $5,000 loan from the broker. Your broker requires a 30% equity maintenance margin, meaning the value of your holdings must stay above $7,000 (30% of $10,000). If the value of your account drops to $6,500, the broker will issue a margin call, asking you to deposit additional funds or sell securities. If you don’t meet the margin call, the broker will sell enough of your holdings to bring your equity back above $7,000, even if it means selling assets you didn’t intend to sell.

Protecting Your Investments

Understanding the processes behind brokerage account sales can help you better protect your investments. Here are a few strategies to safeguard your portfolio:

1. Understand Your Investment Policy Statement (IPS)

Your IPS is your roadmap to investing. It outlines your financial goals, risk tolerance, and the strategies your broker should use. Review your IPS regularly to ensure it still reflects your objectives. If your financial situation changes, update your IPS to avoid any discrepancies that could lead to unnecessary sales.

2. Keep Track of Your Margin Account

If you use a margin account, always know your equity level and stay ahead of margin calls. By keeping a close eye on your margin balance, you can take proactive measures to avoid forced liquidation.

3. Communicate Regularly with Your Broker

Establish open communication with your broker. Ensure they are aware of your preferences and that they fully understand your investment goals. If you have a discretionary account, check in periodically to ensure your broker is adhering to your IPS.

4. Know When You Can Dispute Sales

If you disagree with any sale made in your brokerage account, whether it’s a discretionary account sale or a forced liquidation due to a margin call, you have the right to dispute the decision. Start by discussing the issue with your broker and escalate it to the brokerage firm’s compliance department if necessary. If you still feel that your concerns are unresolved, contact regulatory bodies like the SEC for further investigation.

5. Diversify Your Portfolio

Diversification is a powerful tool to protect against forced liquidation. By spreading your investments across different asset classes, sectors, and geographic regions, you can reduce the risk of a significant loss that might trigger a margin call. Diversification helps buffer your portfolio during market downturns, making it less likely that you’ll need to sell investments at a loss.

Conclusion

Brokerage account sales are an important aspect of managing your investments, but they can raise concerns if they happen unexpectedly. Whether through discretionary account sales or due to a margin call, there are clear reasons behind these actions. Understanding how these processes work, especially how discretionary accounts and margin calls function, will help you protect your investments and ensure that your financial goals remain on track.

To avoid surprises, stay informed about your brokerage account sales and communicate regularly with your broker. Keep your investment policy statement updated and make sure you have enough margin to avoid forced liquidation. With these steps in mind, you can navigate the complexities of brokerage account sales with confidence and protect your investments for the long term.

Click here to read our latest article Start Smarter with a Forex Mini Account