When economic uncertainty strikes, one critical question dominates the minds of investors and traders: Forex vs Commodities – which is better to trade in a crisis year? This dilemma surfaces every time markets crash, economies tumble, or global tensions rise. In times of extreme risk, choosing the right asset class is not just about profit—it’s about survival.

Both forex and commodities behave differently during financial turbulence. Some traders chase currency swings, while others run toward gold and silver for safety. But how do you know which market suits the moment? In this guide, we’ll break down the dynamics of each during crises, compare their behaviors, and help you decide where to focus your trading efforts during a volatile year.

Understanding Market Reactions in a Crisis

Before comparing forex vs commodities, it’s essential to understand how different markets behave under pressure. A crisis could be anything from a pandemic or war to inflation spikes or a banking collapse. The root cause shapes the behavior of both forex pairs and commodity prices.

Currencies respond to monetary policies, central bank actions, and capital flows. Commodities react more to supply and demand shocks, geopolitical disruptions, and inflation concerns. This creates distinct trading opportunities across both asset classes.

In recent crisis years, such as 2008, 2020, and 2022, the markets experienced extreme volatility. Traders who understood market volatility in crisis years positioned themselves ahead of the curve and profited while others panicked.

Why Forex Can Shine in Times of Crisis?

The forex market is the most liquid and dynamic financial arena globally. With over $7 trillion traded daily, it remains accessible even when equities freeze or commodities suffer delivery disruptions.

There are several reasons why trading forex during economic crisis years becomes highly attractive:

• Currencies like the U.S. dollar, Japanese yen, and Swiss franc act as safe haven assets.
• Major forex pairs remain liquid around the clock, even in extreme volatility.
• Central bank policies often move currencies fast, creating high-frequency trading opportunities.
• You can go long or short easily, offering flexibility during panic-driven moves.

For example, during the COVID-19 crash in March 2020, the U.S. dollar initially soared as a safe haven, while emerging market currencies fell dramatically. The Turkish lira, South African rand, and Brazilian real saw rapid declines. At the same time, the yen strengthened due to its safe haven appeal.

Traders who understood the correlation between risk sentiment and currency flow made substantial profits. Market volatility in crisis years like 2020 proves that forex provides short-term opportunities unlike any other.

Commodities: Real Value During Uncertainty

On the other side of the equation, commodities shine when fear of inflation or geopolitical risk surges. Assets like gold and silver have held their place as traditional hedges for centuries.

Trading during economic crisis periods often leads to increased interest in physical assets. This is especially true when fiat currencies look unstable or central banks start massive money-printing operations.

Gold prices shot above $2,000 in both 2020 and 2022 as investors ran from paper assets. Silver followed closely, especially during fears of industrial disruption. Commodities like oil, wheat, and copper also surged when global supply chains were disrupted during conflicts like the Russia-Ukraine war.

Key reasons commodities are some of the best assets to trade in a crisis include:

• They offer intrinsic value, making them reliable safe haven assets.
• Inflationary concerns tend to boost commodity prices, especially precious metals.
• Physical scarcity or logistical problems can cause sudden price spikes.
• Institutional investors often rotate into commodities for portfolio protection.

Commodity traders who timed their entries well—such as long positions on gold futures during Fed rate cuts—earned strong gains in crisis years. Understanding how market volatility in crisis years impacts commodities can give traders a powerful edge.

Comparing Forex vs Commodities Head-to-Head

To make the right choice between forex and commodities during a crisis year, you need a clear comparison of their characteristics. Below are critical factors that traders should evaluate:

• Liquidity: Forex wins hands down. Currencies can be traded 24/5 with tight spreads.
• Volatility: Both markets are volatile, but commodities can experience sharper, more sudden spikes.
• Accessibility: Forex requires lower capital and is beginner-friendly. Commodities may involve higher margin requirements.
• Economic Sensitivity: Forex responds quickly to macroeconomic changes. Commodities react to geopolitical events and supply shocks.
• Safe Haven Appeal: Forex offers safe havens like USD and JPY. Commodities provide gold and silver.

In terms of trading during economic crisis conditions, your asset choice should reflect the root cause of the crisis. Is it inflation, war, or a financial meltdown? The answer should guide your strategy.

When to Prioritize Forex in Crisis Years

Forex should be your primary focus if the crisis involves monetary policy shifts, rate cuts, or liquidity crunches. For example, the 2008 and 2020 crashes were largely monetary and banking-related events.

Here’s when forex becomes the better trade:

• Central banks are reacting fast with policy changes.
• The crisis creates massive shifts in interest rates and currency values.
• Safe haven currencies are gaining strength.
• Economic data is causing large intraday moves.

Consider trading USD/JPY during U.S. banking panics or EUR/USD when ECB intervention becomes likely. These pairs offer fast execution, tight spreads, and high directional potential.

Also, during crisis periods, many traders employ carry trade unwinds. They exit high-yielding currencies like AUD or NZD in favor of the yen or franc. These movements can be explosive and highly profitable.

When Commodities Offer the Edge

Commodities should take center stage if the crisis involves inflation, resource scarcity, or geopolitical disruption. Think of wars, sanctions, or massive stimulus programs. These events fuel commodity rallies, especially in gold, silver, and oil.

Best times to favor commodities:

• Inflation fears dominate headlines.
• The U.S. dollar weakens sharply due to monetary easing.
• Wars or natural disasters disrupt global supply chains.
• Commodity inventories fall or production halts.

Traders who bought crude oil futures during supply shortages or gold when central banks expanded their balance sheets outperformed many equity investors. Safe haven assets like gold and silver act as hedges against fiat debasement and systemic collapse.

Silver also becomes interesting when industrial usage remains strong. For instance, increased demand in the green energy sector has made silver a dual-purpose asset—both industrial and monetary.

How to Build a Smart Crisis Trading Strategy?

The best approach may not be choosing forex vs commodities, but learning to trade both intelligently. Diversification offers protection and profit when uncertainty peaks.

Here’s how to create a balanced crisis-year strategy:

• Use forex for short-term volatility trades based on news or rate moves.
• Hold commodities like gold for longer-term inflation or fear hedging.
• Monitor central bank meetings and geopolitical headlines daily.
• Keep risk exposure limited with tight stop-losses and position sizing.
• Rotate between assets based on changing crisis dynamics.

Also, consider using ETFs for commodities if you want easier access. Instruments like GLD (gold), SLV (silver), or USO (oil) provide exposure without needing a futures account.

Meanwhile, in forex, major pairs like EUR/USD or USD/JPY remain ideal for technical and fundamental traders. Use trendlines, moving averages, and sentiment indicators to spot high-probability setups during volatile months.

Real-World Examples of Asset Behavior in Crisis Years

Let’s look at a few quick examples from recent history that show how each market performs:

2020 Pandemic Crisis:

• Forex: USD initially surged, then weakened after Fed liquidity flood.
• Commodities: Gold and silver hit multi-year highs as safe haven assets.

2022 Ukraine War:

• Forex: Russian ruble collapsed and then recovered with capital controls.
• Commodities: Oil and wheat prices soared due to sanctions and shortages.

2008 Global Financial Crisis:

• Forex: Yen strengthened dramatically as carry trades unwound.
• Commodities: Gold fell initially but later soared during inflation recovery.

In each case, both markets offered profitable opportunities—if traders understood the nature of the crisis and acted accordingly.

Conclusion: Which One Should You Trade?

So, forex vs commodities—what’s better to trade in a crisis year?

The answer lies in the type of crisis. If monetary policy, liquidity, or central bank actions dominate the news, forex is your go-to market. But if inflation, war, or commodity scarcity drive fear, commodities offer stronger returns.

You don’t need to pick just one. Blend them wisely. Use forex for short-term tactical plays and commodities for long-term crisis hedges. That’s how seasoned traders survive and thrive when markets are under siege.

In times of high market volatility in crisis years, your edge comes not from the asset—but from how well you understand it. Choose wisely, trade smart, and remember—crisis years create some of the best opportunities for the prepared.

Click here to read our latest article How Trade Wars Are Affecting Safe Haven Assets in 2025?